![]() |
| "The Right Room" (2025) Photographer: Daren Stahl Actors: Cole Tarantowski, Rachel Gold Costume Designer: Serenity Grace Tate Director: Jasmine Renee Intimacy Director: Julia Fisher |
Just to break this down; you can create a page for your company, or for yourself as a business, for free. It’s good to do this; I have a personal page and also a professional page on Facebook, so there’s a place for party pictures and political opinions, and another for my work as a writer.
It doesn’t bother me that I can’t link more than one blog post to my professional page for free anymore, because really, who cares?
But if you are a community theater, for example, and you are trying to promote your latest show, you now cannot post more than two links to your website or event page or positive news articles without upgrading to a paid account.
“What to do?” they ask.
Well, obviously, you pay for the account.
This has been the long-con of social media, and the internet in general: that everything we used to pay for is now free! Music is free! Programs are free! Advertising is free! And now we’re being made to pay?
As Homer Simpson once said after enjoying a free sample at the grocery store, “So that’s your little plan! Get us addicted, then jack up the price.”
He then said, “Okay, you win.”
“But ours is a small theater, we can’t afford advertising! What are we supposed to do?”
I sympathize. I get it. But listen to yourself. You say, “I can’t afford advertising,” as though advertising hasn’t always been paid for, by everyone, throughout history. Except, apparently, for the past twenty years.
In the pre-internet days, I was a member of a small, independent theater company. We obsessed about getting the word out. This was in the early 1990s, just before the web broke. Before everyone had email.
We created hand drawn art. We used Word for typography. We printed the flyers at the copy shop. We drove and walked around town and posted them in storefronts, and handed them out to people. It took time. “What were we supposed to do?”
We didn’t really have a “budget,” our overhead wasn’t enormous. We rented a building, some of us lived in the apartments in that building to help pay for the rent of the building. We charged admission for the shows. We paid for copies. And we bought advertising, in the form of newspaper ads, postcards and postage, and sometimes even radio ads.
We also sent PSA scripts to local non-profit stations, and press releases to all the local papers. We invested in a fax modem, which meant we could type up a press release, send it over the landline and it would be printed on paper there, at the newspaper or television or radio office, on their dime.
This has been the long-con of social media, and the internet in general: that everything we used to pay for is now free! Music is free! Programs are free! Advertising is free! And now we’re being made to pay?
![]() |
| The Simpsons S2:E16 "Barts Dog Gets an F" |
He then said, “Okay, you win.”
“But ours is a small theater, we can’t afford advertising! What are we supposed to do?”
I sympathize. I get it. But listen to yourself. You say, “I can’t afford advertising,” as though advertising hasn’t always been paid for, by everyone, throughout history. Except, apparently, for the past twenty years.
In the pre-internet days, I was a member of a small, independent theater company. We obsessed about getting the word out. This was in the early 1990s, just before the web broke. Before everyone had email.
We created hand drawn art. We used Word for typography. We printed the flyers at the copy shop. We drove and walked around town and posted them in storefronts, and handed them out to people. It took time. “What were we supposed to do?”
We didn’t really have a “budget,” our overhead wasn’t enormous. We rented a building, some of us lived in the apartments in that building to help pay for the rent of the building. We charged admission for the shows. We paid for copies. And we bought advertising, in the form of newspaper ads, postcards and postage, and sometimes even radio ads.
![]() |
| "Mind Your Own Business" (1994) Art: Rich Weiss Layout: David Hansen |
We had a second, designated phone line for people to call to hear entertaining messages and learn up-to-date information about what was happening at the theater that week.
And for our efforts we were contacted by media outlets for interviews. And in this manner, people heard about what we were doing and came to see our shows.
So you can’t post a link for your show for free more than twice a month on your professional Facebook page. "What are we supposed to do?" Something else, I guess. Use your imagination, do some leg work, and yes, spend some money for your advertising. Appreciate that it was only ever meant to be free for a short while, and deal with it.
Which brings us to the subject of so-called “artificial intelligence.” The other day Anthropic, creator of Claude, went public and made a trillion dollars. If I used “trillion” in a sentence twenty years ago, I was probably being sarcastic about something.
“Oh, sure. Times a trillion. Whatever.”
Point is, generative AI isn’t going away any time soon. Neither is Weezer. That doesn’t mean it doesn’t suck.
It is so disheartening to see my fellow theater creators using generative AI to create advertisements to promote their work. Playwrights, I notice, are particularly guilty of this, they are trying to promote their new, unproduced scripts, and use these online resources to crank out instant graphics for free.
But they aren’t free. They are theft. Like downloading copyrighted mp3s in the early 2000s, just because something is easy and you can do it from the safety of your own home doesn’t mean it’s not unethical, harmful and wrong.
Four points before we continue:
Now, let me tell you a story, one with a valuable lesson: Don’t drink and post.
One evening this past summer, I was doomscrolling in bed, always a bad thing to do. I saw yet another piece of AI slop in a post promoting some other playwright’s work. In this case, it was about an historical figure who, incidentally, I had also written about recently, and so I had a knee-jerk reaction.
I wrote, “Did you use generative AI to create your script?” I put down my phone and went to sleep.
The next morning, I saw that in the intervening seven hours there were numerous responses to my snark, dunking on my page, my work, that I write “fine plays” (my words, it’s supposed to be cute), how few followers I have, and so on. I deleted my comment and moved on with my morning, because that's what you do.
It was later that I noticed that the offended playwright had sent me a message through FB Messenger and also to my personal email that he was suing me for defamation.
More about the playwright, though: every single graphic they use to promote their work is in the same, predictable, AI sloppy style, with an uncanny image over a sepia-and-urine toned background. For one production he has even “created” two very similar but different images of the same historic figure; one of the subject himself, the other of an actor who once played him in a very successful film. It’s ridiculous. The play is being produced, why not take a picture of the actor playing that character in your show? Everyone has a camera.
We are allowed to assume that anyone who feels no compunction about using AI to promote their work would feel no compunction about using AI in the work itself. You put yourself into the position of explaining to the world which part of your work is plagiarized and which isn’t.
“But I can’t afford to pay for a graphic designer!” they say. Maybe, maybe not. But when you use generative AI you’re not Jean Valjean, you’re not stealing bread to feed your hungry family. You are choosing to engage in the theft of imagery created by others without credit or recompense.
Promotion used to be in the budget, and that’s where it belongs again. The photographers, the graphic designers, the people who they themselves support the arts and will give you a better deal than they would a commercial enterprise, because they get it. Reach out to them. Ask around. Or create it yourself.
What made you create your work in the first place? Draw upon those desires and impulses to engage others in promoting your work.
And for our efforts we were contacted by media outlets for interviews. And in this manner, people heard about what we were doing and came to see our shows.
So you can’t post a link for your show for free more than twice a month on your professional Facebook page. "What are we supposed to do?" Something else, I guess. Use your imagination, do some leg work, and yes, spend some money for your advertising. Appreciate that it was only ever meant to be free for a short while, and deal with it.
Which brings us to the subject of so-called “artificial intelligence.” The other day Anthropic, creator of Claude, went public and made a trillion dollars. If I used “trillion” in a sentence twenty years ago, I was probably being sarcastic about something.
“Oh, sure. Times a trillion. Whatever.”
Point is, generative AI isn’t going away any time soon. Neither is Weezer. That doesn’t mean it doesn’t suck.
![]() |
| Good one. Credit: Ramin Nasibov |
But they aren’t free. They are theft. Like downloading copyrighted mp3s in the early 2000s, just because something is easy and you can do it from the safety of your own home doesn’t mean it’s not unethical, harmful and wrong.
Four points before we continue:
- Your “AI created” image was computer generated from countless other (often but not exclusively copyrighted) works created by human beings who will never receive compensation nor recognition for their efforts. You have stolen from them.
- The data centers that created your “AI created” image use an unsustainable amount of water and electricity. You are stealing from the future.
- There are so many wonderful creators out there who would love to work with you to create an original image for your new work. You can’t afford to pay them? Fine. You’d rather steal from them? Not fine.
- Your AI generated graphic looks like shit.
- “AI generated graphics aren’t stealing.” (Whatever gets you through the night.)
- “AI is inevitable.” (Hopeless take, but okay.)
- “I don’t want to talk about it.” (All right, but don’t expect me to support your work.)
![]() |
| From "1984" by George Orwell Image: Suzanna Hamilton from the 1984 film directed by Michael Radford |
One evening this past summer, I was doomscrolling in bed, always a bad thing to do. I saw yet another piece of AI slop in a post promoting some other playwright’s work. In this case, it was about an historical figure who, incidentally, I had also written about recently, and so I had a knee-jerk reaction.
I wrote, “Did you use generative AI to create your script?” I put down my phone and went to sleep.
The next morning, I saw that in the intervening seven hours there were numerous responses to my snark, dunking on my page, my work, that I write “fine plays” (my words, it’s supposed to be cute), how few followers I have, and so on. I deleted my comment and moved on with my morning, because that's what you do.
It was later that I noticed that the offended playwright had sent me a message through FB Messenger and also to my personal email that he was suing me for defamation.
RE: FORMAL DEMAND TO CEASE AND DESIST; RETRACTION AND CORRECTION; PRESERVATION OF EVIDENCE; AND DEMAND FOR PAYMENT
Mr. Hansen: This letter constitutes a formal demand concerning false and defamatory public statements you have made asserting or implying that I use artificial intelligence (“AI”) to write my plays.
It goes on, a very legal and correct and possibly AI-generated demand for reparation and $10,000 in damages. I had already deleted the evidence (i.e.: a Facebook comment) though I’m sure he took a screenshot, just as I took a screenshot of them leaving a “laugh” emoji on my recent announcement that I would be reviving my one-man play about the stillbirth of our first son, mockery which I may legally state caused me emotional distress, and as the result of this extreme, outrageous conduct, done intentionally or recklessly, caused me severe emotional harm.
![]() |
| "Sin" poster (1999) Design by David Hansen |
We are allowed to assume that anyone who feels no compunction about using AI to promote their work would feel no compunction about using AI in the work itself. You put yourself into the position of explaining to the world which part of your work is plagiarized and which isn’t.
“But I can’t afford to pay for a graphic designer!” they say. Maybe, maybe not. But when you use generative AI you’re not Jean Valjean, you’re not stealing bread to feed your hungry family. You are choosing to engage in the theft of imagery created by others without credit or recompense.
Promotion used to be in the budget, and that’s where it belongs again. The photographers, the graphic designers, the people who they themselves support the arts and will give you a better deal than they would a commercial enterprise, because they get it. Reach out to them. Ask around. Or create it yourself.
What made you create your work in the first place? Draw upon those desires and impulses to engage others in promoting your work.
Be creative. Don't be lazy. Don’t use generative AI.




.jpg)

No comments:
Post a Comment